…Like a Girl: Lauren Greenfield

(Last Updated On: February 18, 2016)

A reader just informed me of a video recently posted on YouTube. It is an advertisement in the form of a casting call asking women and girls what it means to do things “like a girl”. The video is part of a new campaign by Always, a feminine-hygiene brand of Proctor & Gamble, with the premise of boosting adolescent girls’ self-confidence. As in practically all advertising, there is no shortage of hyperbolic bravado.

“We’re kicking off an epic battle to make sure that girls everywhere keep their confidence throughout puberty and beyond…”

To give the video a feel of genuine documentary, the company hired Lauren Greenfield with a track record of films focusing on the realities and tragedies of growing up in “the shadow of Hollywood” such as girls lamenting that they are not yet old enough to get cosmetic surgery—legal with parental consent at age 15. It is true that Greenfield has witnessed one of the most destructive forms of peer pressure revolving around money but, true to form, savvy advertisers focus on a superficial catch phrase and use it to create the impression that their client is a good corporate citizen. The catch phrase is neither the real problem nor the key to a real solution.

First, we see some adults act out actions like “run like a girl”, “throw like a girl”, “fight like a girl”, etc. to illustrate the stereotype and then young girls are brought in—presumably not yet affected by the stereotype—to show that doing it like a girl just means doing their best. The first girl shown is Dakota (age 10) and is followed with cuts of many others. The unfortunate thing about commercial advertisements is that they are not required to credit the actors like they do in other films, so nothing is really known about the girls.

Lauren Greenfield - Always LikeAGirl (2014) (1)

Lauren Greenfield – Always LikeAGirl (2014) (1)

Lauren Greenfield - Always LikeAGirl (2014) (2)

Lauren Greenfield – Always LikeAGirl (2014) (2)

Lauren Greenfield - Always LikeAGirl (2014) (3)

Lauren Greenfield – Always LikeAGirl (2014) (3)

As I reminded readers in ‘The Publicity Dilemma’, corporations are mandated to make the maximum profit possible and whenever they engage in public goodwill campaigns, there is necessarily (and legally) a less noble agenda behind it. Sometimes, it is just a short-term PR effort to compensate for some bad press the company may have received. But in this and many other cases, the company conducts an ongoing effort to foster an image of genuine concern over a specific demographic meant to enhance customer loyalty. As explained in ‘State of the Art Exploitation’, the younger the better and so we see a subtle attempt here to target girls who are not yet ready to use their products.

It is also something of an insult to girls’ intelligence that—at the “tender” age of ten—they do not already understand this stereotype or would be emotionally affected by it if it weren’t for the meanness at which it was hurled at them. It is still commonplace for marketers—with varying degrees of subtlety—to treat girls and women condescendingly. A strong illustration of this can be seen in ‘The Tyranny of Cheerfulness’.

In their campaign, Always encourages girls to offer their feedback and we can expect them not to heed or post any dissenting opinions. Therefore, in the interest of fairness, I invite girls and women to use Pigtails in Paint as a venue for expressing their disdain for such a cynical campaign. Be advised that I, too, have editorial control and will not allow this site to become a hate fest!

2 thoughts on “…Like a Girl: Lauren Greenfield

  1. “Always encourages girls to offer their feedback and we can expect them not to heed or post any dissenting opinions. Therefore, in the interest of fairness, I invite girls and women to use Pigtails in Paint as a venue for expressing their disdain for such a cynical campaign. Be advised that I, too, have editorial control and will not allow this site to become a hate fest!”

    So you encourage people here to post “dissenting opinions” on your blog but if you’ll gladly censor them if you don’t like them.
    ———————-

    • I am not impressed by clever arguments. It seems you have completely missed the point I was making or are mischievously laying some hate bait. But you took the trouble to make your comment and I need to express myself a little more anyway. I removed one statement that was clearly gratuitously hateful. If you would like your ideas to be seen by others, I ask you to give more thoughtful and considered comments.
      It is not a matter of “liking” or disliking. I strongly believe in the free speech of ideas, but that requires rational thought which gets too easy washed away by emotional impulses such as hate. As can be seen throughout the internet, whenever commenters are not screened to stay on topic or allowed to vent under the cloak of anonymity, it diminishes the value of the site.
      Another thing that most people–especially men–don’t realize is how hostile an environment the internet can be for girls and women who want to express serious thoughts that others might object to. I want Pigtails to be a safe place for girls and women and my editorial choices will reflect that.
      Incidentally, for those who are interested, a hypocrite is someone who professes one thing and then does another. If any readers feel that my writing demonstrates any kind of hypocrisy, please give me a specific example so I can clarify it if necessary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *